Showing posts with label Sarawak election. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sarawak election. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 19, 2011

The myths of S'wak polls results


Bridget Welsh
Apr 19, 11

COMMENT The dust has begun to settle on the 10th Sarawak polls with the BN touting its retention of the two-thirds majority as a victory, while Pakatan Rakyat points to the more than doubling of its seats. This was the most competitive state election in Sarawak's history and was hard fought by both sides.

BN, led by Prime Minister Najib Razak essentially camped in the state for 10 days to assure the two-thirds, while the opposition also focused is national machinery in Sarawak, bringing in the top guns from Peninsular Malaysia and thousands of party workers.

A closer look at the results show that the opposition has made impressive ground, despite its failure to break the two-thirds threshold. Sarawak is no longer BN's fixed deposit, and trends in mobilisation and support suggest that it is even more likely not to be so unless Sarawak BN radically changes how it governs.

Myth of Chinese-only swing

The spin on this election reflects a similar tone of 2006, focusing on the gains in urban seats and Chinese voters. The implicit threat in Chief Minister Abdul Taib Mahmud's statement that the Chinese will pay for their lack of loyalty highlights the perception that the losses are the product of continued Chinese support for the opposition.

In terms of sheer number of voters for the opposition, this is correct. In all the Chinese-majority seats - from Padungan to Bukit Assek - the level of support for the opposition increased, both in number of votes and share of the vote.

NONEThis reflected the dynamic - almost electrifying - opposition campaign in the urban areas, especially in Miri where voters experienced the political awakening that their counterparts in Kuching had experienced in 2006, and in Sibu at the 2010 by-election.

No question about it, a growing number of Chinese supported the opposition in Sarawak. The interesting finding from the results, however, is that they are not alone, and in fact the Chinese swing toward the opposition is comparatively less (yes, less) than the changes within other communities.

By comparing the 2011 results with those of 2006, I trace the changes in voter turnout and share of support (percentage of majority among voters who turned out to vote) for the opposition at the seat level and, when appropriate and with available data, the polling stream level.

azlanThe preliminary findings highlight that the movement is greatest in mixed constituencies, and significant movement occurred across the ethnic communities, even the Malays.

Let's begin with the mobilisation of voters across ethnicities. The 2011 polls show an impressive increase in voter turnout, in keeping with the increased competitiveness of the election. The greatest turnout increase was among the Malays, where the PBB machinery was well-honed, as more voters were brought to the polls, followed by increased participation of Chinese and Iban voters.

What this impressive increase in mobilisation across groups reveals is that Sarawakians recognised their power as voters and came out to vote in an unprecedented manner. This highlights the growing appreciation of political power in Sarawak and engagement with politics, which is in keeping with the unprecedented crowds at ceramah across the state, even in the rural areas.

azlanThe table (left) also highlights that the change in voting across the ethnic communities. The greatest movement compared to 2006 was in mixed seats, followed by movement in the Orang Ulu community in places such as Ba'Kelalan (where Baru Bian won his seat) but also places such as Telang Usan.

The share of movement in Orang Ulu-majority seats is large, a 20% swing. These numbers can be a bit deceiving in that the actual numbers of voters in Sarawak are small and 20% can reflect a small number of voters in the small constituencies, yet nevertheless, the swing is significant.

Ibans and Bidayuhs too change loyalities

Why then, given the swing, did the seats not move into opposition hands? The reason is simple - before 2011 opposition support in some of these areas was minuscule. In many constituencies, the opposition needed more than a 40% change to win. Yet there has been a very large swing, which is much larger than the swing in Peninsular Malaysia in 2008.

From my perspective, the most interesting ethnic changes occurred in the Malay/Melanau, Iban and Bidayuh areas. A look at the seat tally suggests that Malays are squarely in the BN camp. The PBB won all 35 of its seats and PAS failed to win a single seat, even in the close contest of Beting Maro.

The Malay/Melanau seats are interesting in a number of ways. First, the pattern towards the opposition varies, with a few of the seats moving even more strongly toward the BN, such as Sadong Jaya, and as such, the pattern is uneven.

Yet the Malay/Melanau ground was more competitive with more straight fights and more contests, such as in Daro and Dalat. PAS, in particular, made inroads. To suggest that the Malay/Melanau community is firmly behind the BN is wrong. Their support is changing as well, in spite of the ethnic campaigning and use of the racial card.

The Iban and Bidayuh majority seats also followed the pattern of opposition gains. In Iban areas, there was less movement in the share of the vote and like the Malay/Melanau seats the pattern was not consistent across seats toward the opposition, with some increased support towards the BN in Engkilili, but overall, the Iban have also changed loyalties.

azlanAs is shown in this table (right), this occurred most starkly in semi-rural areas.

The Bidayuh seats were seen to be those that would have determined whether the opposition broke the two-thirds or not. Pakatan hoped to pick up at least three of these Bidayuh seats, as sentiment on the ground toward the BN had shifted due to the religious issues and persistent exclusion of this group from economic benefits.

Higher education among the Bidayuh had increased awareness and exposure to political issues. The opposition failed to win a single seat, but here too the gains in the share of majority were impressive - an estimated 17.9% swing.

The bottom line is that the view that this election was the product of a bifurcated pattern of support - Chinese with the opposition and other groups with the BN - is wrong. Every group expressed serious concerns with the BN, and this was driven primarily with angst toward the long tenure and perceived excesses of the chief minister.

The urban voters myth

It is thus not surprising that given the changes across the board across ethnic communities, another myth needs to be shattered, namely that the opposition support is only in the urban areas.

Much has been made that the opposition won two very rural seats, Ba'kelalan and Krian. Yet, the most significant gains in terms of seats were in the semi-rural areas - for example, Batu Kawah, Dudong, Piasau (which has a large semi-rural area). The close fight in Senadin is also illustrative.

My preliminary analysis at the seat level shows that the gains in semi-rural seats were more than in the other areas, 19.7% compared to 14.8% in the rural areas and 13.4% in the urban communities.

NONEThe 'safe' seats in the urban periphery are no longer 'safe'. The change in voting pattern reflected not just Chinese support for Pakatan, but Iban and Bidayuh support as well. In fact, what is especially interesting is that the movement in support in rural areas is more than the share in urban areas (although it is important to note that the urban areas have more voters).

More than anything, these findings point illustrate how much the 'fixed deposit' is no longer secure. Semi-rural and rural cracks in BN support are part of the new Sarawak, a more competitive polity that has become increasingly receptive to a stronger two-party system and critical of BN governance, especially in the areas of corruption.

The growing youth revolution


The election of young candidates in the opposition in some cases fresh out to university may come as a surprise to some, but it highlights the final important dynamic in this election, the massive movement among young voters away from the BN.

Chong Snr ceramah in kuchingDrawing from the study of 'saluran' results in seven seats so far, from the Miri, Kuching and Bidayuh areas (semi-rural and urban seats), the findings suggest that a youth revolt has occurred.

In the lower polling streams, where new voters are concentrated, more than 70% of voters opposed the BN. Given the largely young crowds at rallies, especially in Kuching and Miri, this is no surprise.

We see two pattern - higher mobilisation of younger voters, an estimated 16% increase in turnout compared to older voters, and an overwhelming level of support for Pakatan among younger voters in the lower streams, with a change in trend of over 25%. In 2006, there was already stronger support for the opposition among the youth, but this appears to have significantly increased.

azlanWhen one considers the high number of younger voters that did not register, estimated in the 100,000s in Sarawak, and the large number of younger voters working outstation, these results should be quite worrying for the BN indeed. The fact that the election came before Gawai (harvest festival) is also important as it is likely that when younger voters returned home possibly further movement from the BN could have occurred.

Many a younger voter in my exit interviews highlighted the fact that they convinced their parents (and grandparents) to change support. The youthful composition of voting this election compared to 2006 shows that indeed a revolution among younger voters has occurred in Sarawak.

Rise of a new Sarawak

These results are preliminary and need to further confirmed with the official results at the 'saluran' (polling stream) level. This analysis is drawn from the newspaper publication of results and 'saluran' results that have been made available immediately after the polls, so the numbers should be seen as indicators of trends rather than absolutes.

These findings collectively show that there is indeed a new Sarawak, that voters across races, across geographic areas and especially the state's future are no longer supporting the BN to the same degree. While the two-thirds may not have been broken, profound political change did come to Sarawak.

It remains to be seen whether the opposition can continue the momentum or the BN will address the root causes of the discontent, but irrespective of this, Sarawak remains critical for the political direction of the country - now more than ever.


DR BRIDGET WELSH is associate professor of political science at Singapore Management University and she can be reached at bwelsh@smu.edu.sg. She was in Sarawak to observe the state election.

Source: http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/161869

Friday, April 15, 2011

LET US BE FAIR TO BOTH SIDES OF THE ELECTIONS CAMPAIGN

As reported in The Star, 15.04.2011

KUCHING: The Association of Churches Sarawak has expressed regret that DAP, PAS and PKR leaders held a press conference on the association's meeting with them Thursday concerning the Bahasa Malaysia bibles issue.

ACS secretary-general Ambrose Linang said the breakfast meeting was held behind closed doors after the leaders agreed to the association's request not to hold a press conference regarding it.

“Our association received an invitation from Selangor state executive councillor Teresa Kok to have a breakfast meeting with the leaders of these opposition parties and agreed on condition that political issues would not be discussed as we are non-partisan.

“Shortly after the meeting we left. However, we were disappointed to learn that these leaders held a press conference later,” he said when contacted by Bernama.

Ambrose said the association would study the statements made at the press conference, and if there were political elements, it would issue an official statement. (Bernama)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

As clarified by YB Teresa Kok, 15.04.2011, 1.30 am

Association of Churches Sarawak (ACS) whacked Pakatan Rakyat (PR) as reported by Bernama. My response to Malaysian Insider is: We have agreed to have a closed door meeting and not to have press conference with the church leaders but we were never asked not to disclose issues that were being discussed to the media. In fact even if we (PR) don't have meeting with ACS, all leaders in the Pakatan have been saying all these issues in our political ralliews and meeting the people sessions during the elections campaign. We just repeated the same thing when we met with ACS leaders.

However, we appreciate the meeting with ACS leaders and we understand their situation. I believe they are under tremendous pressures and that is why they made such statement (as reported in Bernama).

We were told not to allow the media to come in to take photos and to make our meeting with ACS a closed door meeting. We have done that.

But how can we not speak to the media after the closed door dialogue session when the media were waiting outside? All these church leaders have seen the presence of the media when they arrived and they have seen us not allowing media to enter the room to take pictures too. It is understood that we will have our own press conference after meeting them and reiterate our stand on issues related to Christians and churches.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

My take

I am laying the Bernama report and YB Teresa Kok's response side by side for Christian leaders to have their respective two perspectives because during this Sarawak elections campaign, the playing field has not been level. On TV and the printed media, the Malaysian public have not been given more than perfunctory coverage of the opposition campaign and statements; it has been pretty much only the BN campaign that has been relayed by the mainstream media.

On the PR-ACS meeting, despite Bernama's prompt objective or insistence to report ACS' unhappiness about PR's press conference after the meeting, in fact whatever PR said of the meeting at the press conference was not reported in the mainstream media. So what is there to object to? Even the Bernama report about this meeting only carried the ACS' reaction to the press conference held by PR and that too because Bernama specifically asked for a comment from the ACS secretary.

And what do we as a Christian community in Malaysia find so wrong about PR taking up the issues which CFM and MCCBCHST have been raising? The main message PR has declared on this issue is that short of the attorney-general withdrawing the appeal to the High Court's ruling on the "Allah" issue, the problem will remain regardless of the so-called government's 10-Point solution. Quite frankly, if PR has not voiced these sentiments, the Sarawak elections campaign and the Sarawak voters will only have the federal government's side of the story. How will this benefit the Christian community?

I am taking the trouble to communicate this to Christian leaders because I hear the voice of anguish in Teresa Kok's 1.30 am phone message to me. In a democracy, the voters must have the prerogative to decide who they want to be their representatives in the next state legislative assembly. That can only happen when voters have the opportunity to hear both sides' story.

The Christian Church can only be heard and seen as being truly non-partisan during an electoral process when it treats both sides of the campaign equally. Pardon me if I am wrong but I did not see this equal treatment in Sarawak this past week.

Goh Keat Peng

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

Vote for the Future Generations of Sarawak

Sarawakians are going to the polls on 16th April, 2011. It is the Tenth State-Election. I urge the eligible voters to come out and vote without fear. Make use of your citizen’s right to determine the state’s next leadership. The voters have the responsibility to give their future generations a promising hope.

I always have a passion for Sarawakians as I have been doing my pastoral ministry in Sarawak, based in Kuching, in the early 1990s for four and a half years. Those days our two boys were at tender ages below teen. As West Malaysians, we went into Sarawak with our passports as if we were entering into another country. I applied for a work pass. Regrettably a high ranking immigration officer who was a Christian turned me down. And subsequently my whole family had resorted to flying in and out every three months. Time and money were wasted in such ridiculous hassle!

We then realized that Sarawakians were people who felt insecure with outsiders, including West Malaysians. They thought that West Malaysians were trying to rob away their rice bowls. Even for the people who were given business passes. They needed to fly out every six months. Such an investor-unfriendly policy will eventually cripple their economies.

There is much connection between investment and economy. If Sarawakians look from the anchor of “money being siphoning out” as their priority concern, then efforts will be made to ensure that outsiders cannot stay there for long. If they were to look from the anchor of “opportunity for economy growth”, then will they welcome those outsiders! Wherever there are business activities, there are growth and prosperity.

About four years ago my wife went back to Kuching after years of absence. She was appalled to see that there was not much development ever since we left. In fact, it seemed that the city was getting more stagnant. I was not surprised to hear about that. The strict immigration laws have either caused businesses to pull out or no new ones wanted to come in. Today we see lots of Sarawakians and Sabahans working in West Malaysia. Such scenario just speaks louder than words.

Who have made the Sarawakians so kiasu (scared of losing) then? The corrupt ruling representatives, of course! Sarawak has the riches natural resources in Malaysia, including timber and petroleum. Yet it is the second poorest state in the country, after Terengganu! By the way, Terengganu also has rich oil fields. So either the leadership of Sarawak was incompetent or they simply abused the state resources. Evidently it was found to be of the latter.

It is sad that citizen there at large have been instilled with such thoughts as rejecting the “rice bowl robbers” until they were convinced it was a truth. And subsequently they accepted the “fact” that they are poorer and less competent than the West Malaysians. By riding on the heresy, now the desperate Barisan Nasional leaders told the voters to reject Political Parties from West Malaysia.

By giving such an advice, they were actually slapping on the Prime Minister Najib Razak over his “1Malaysia” slogan! East and West Malaysians have been divided for too long. Instead of uniting the people, these bankrupt leaders were doing otherwise by dividing us.

So it is time for a new leadership to provide governance. Even as Pakatan Rakyat is pushing for a “Malaysians’ Malaysia”, Sarawakians must consider this time round to make a change in government. Deputy Prime Minister Muhyiddin claimed that BN’s policy of “Transformation” is better than PR’s “Ubah” (Change). If BN has never provided enough the basic infrastructures in the past 48 years, what “transformation” then can you expect from them? It is disgraceful to hear from PR campaigners about their traveling experience on rough road journeys which as if they were riding on boats! Both Najib and Muhyiddin should travel by roads instead of by air. They should experience the shameful states of Taib’s “development”.

Sarawakians should become the catalyst for a Federal Change. Do not miss the opportunity of a lifetime. When the old generations have been deprived of much benefit, enough is enough, think for the future generations. The vast resources of Sarawak are given by God to every Anak Sarawak. Claim back what are rightfully yours.

The only means of bridging up the gap between the East and West is to enlarge the cake of economy in Sarawak. If Penang which has not much natural resources and yet PR ruled Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng could make it the best state in investment index, how much more will Sarawak be, which has the richest natural resources?

We pray for a bright future in Malaysia. All Malaysians shall be prosperous. By then there is no more differentiating each other as an East Malaysian or a West Malaysian. We are all Malaysians, and truly Anak Bangsa Malaysia.

不再分东西马人,而是马来西亚人

我是西马人,在1990年初曾经在砂拉越的教会做了4年多牧师,因此对于这个州有一定的认识。两地虽然是一国,但我全家好像是去到外国,拿着护照申请工作准证。我们不获批准,只好每三个月飞进飞出。

砂拉越人对西马人缺乏安全感,以为外人进去必会抢走自己的饭碗。若以经济的角度分析,这是一种误导。西马人进去少部分是找工作,反而大部分是进行投资。其实以工作机会来说,西马比东马更多机会。我们进去当时的年代,很多西马人在那里做生意,制造了给当地人不少工作的机会。

四年前我太太旧地重游,看见那里并没有什么进展,反而有倒退的现象。原来因着移民厅严峻的限制,很多西马商家不是撤退就是裹足不前。当活动减少,就带动不起经济起飞。所以,今天我们看到许多东马人在西马工作,已经不言而喻!

现在砂拉越进行第10届州选举,国阵打出“转型”牌,民联则打出“改变”牌。无论是转型或改变,目的就是要发展砂拉越。砂拉越的资源,明显比任何州都更丰富,但何竟州民还怕外人抢饭碗呢?原因就是州民仍然贫穷,尤其在城镇以外的子民。而国阵的一些政客更借助州民怕竞争的弱点呼吁他们“拒绝西马政党”。

东马两州已经成为马来西亚的一分子48年了,为何还有人想阻碍东西两地子民合一呢?这已经违背首相纳吉的“一个马来西亚”口号。现在是时候不再分西马人和东马人为自居了,而是大家都是马来西亚人!被南中国海隔开的两岸人民必须破除障碍,拉近我们的关系。唯一能够使到砂拉越人和沙巴人接受西马人的管道就是扩大这两州的经济蛋糕。西马人肯定很乐意协助彼岸的同胞经济崛起的。

无论谁这次执政砂拉越,希望州政府把州丰富的资源还给州民享受。所以投票必须投选那些为州为国的兴旺为大前提之候选人。