Sunday, May 6, 2012

Road to Malaysia's day of destiny



Source:  http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/197081
By Bridget Welsh

With well over 100,000 people gathering last week for electoral reform in the largest street protest in the nation’s history – and the event marred by violence by both state and non-state actors alike – Malaysian politics has reached an important impasse.

The Bersih 3.0 rally and its aftermath reveal that the path ahead for Malaysian politics will grow even more contentious and complex. As the different ‘Bersih stories’ pour in, ranging from ‘ordinary’ heroism to the darker accounts of beatings and abuse of power, the move of Malaysian politics outside of the realm of elite to the streets and social media is both empowering and scary.

Prime Minister Najib Razak’s decision not to accommodate the concerns of the protesters last week, and even to demonise their actions, now prods Malaysia further along the road to its day of destiny, where the political fate of Malaysia’s 54-year government will be determined. So far, the routes chosen are one of confrontation rather than compromise, making resolution to differences even more difficult.

Before the rally, I argued that four actors would shape politics around Bersih 3.0 – the youth, the middle class, the police and East Malaysians. Of these, three were decisive on rally day itself (the latter will grow more so as elections approach).

The youth and the middle-class attended the rally in large numbers, marking a new generation’s engagement with politics and transforming a largely apathetic middle class into a more engaged electorate.

Those wearing yellow and green included Malaysia’s soccer moms, the shopping mall princesses, disgruntled students, retirees and usually reticent professionals.

These individuals comprised those who had for years enjoyed the air-conditioned comfort of Malaysia’s success, yet with different levels of concern and angst chose to brave Kuala Lumpur’s hot and humid conditions on April 28. It was uncomfortable, but overwhelmingly, this embrace of discomfort shows how engaged Malaysians are with hot-button political issues and their willingness to stand up and be counted.

They were there because they see the country moving in the wrong direction and wanted to make it right. At the very least, the Bersih rally revealed the shortcomings of the country’s leaders in addressing the concerns of a large, important and increasing number of its citizens.
Much of the attention focused on the third actor, the police, whose over-the-top actions in the use of tear gas and their attacks on journalists have permanently stained their reputation among those connected to the rally.

For those not at the rally, the picture is less clear as the mainstream media has manipulated the event in an attempt to snatch the moral high ground, with the government going as far as censoring the international media and destroying cameras. Often the characterisation of police action has been one of black and white, where in actual fact there is much more gray, and views are evolving as more and more stories are shared.

Questions will remain about the breaching of the barricade, and unless a truly independent party investigates, the ‘he said, she said’ dynamic will be rife with conspiracy theories that breed confusion and suspicion rather than promote genuine respect for the rule of law.

Ultimately, Malaysian voters will decide on who ordered what and why, as the truth cannot be censored with over 100,000 Malaysians from all walks of life sharing their experiences back inside their air-conditioned homes through a social network that directly and indirectly touched over half of the electorate.

Different narratives

Bersih 3.0 was a nationalistic event, a moment of patriotism. What is striking to see are two conflicting ‘Save Malaysia’ narratives that have emerged. The first is one that is shared by rally attendees and its supporters as those who braved the tear gas decided to come out to ‘save’ the country.

This vision is one in which the event becomes a turning point towards greater freedom and empowerment. The symbolism of Dataran Merdeka runs deep as this nationalist narrative is one of rights and fairness.

The core of electoral reform involves guaranteeing that the voice of the people is heard fairly and freely. As such, for Bersih supporters attending the rally, it was about this democratic image for the country as it hopes to move towards a stronger system based on integrity and inclusion.
This stands in stark contrast to the alternative image based on a more reactionary nationalism, one in which the threat is defined as the protesters, ordinary people, who are challenging the status quo. They were portrayed as attacking the country, first on the police force and then later the incumbent system as a whole.

This government-linked ‘image building’ has attempted to showcase the protesters as national security threats (needing barbed wire), immoral actors who are ‘dirty’ rather than clean. Embedded in this narrative is the image that the protestors are anti-Malay, initially as attackers of the Malay police force and later as supposedly immoral individuals.

It is hate-speech that is reminiscent of regimes that feed on fear and hold onto power through exclusion. Also weaved into this narrative is the image of destabilising reformasi proponent fighting for power in the form of Anwar Ibrahim, who is ironically attacked even further in what can be seen as an effort to bring back the Dr Mahathir Mohamad’s base of supporters into Najib’s political fold.

The efforts to stoke hatred of the Bersih movement and its supporters, especially opposition leaders, are extensive, involving the manipulation of the foreign media and threats against journalists and observers, such as Australia’s Senator Nicholas Xenophon.

This narrative is about using racism and fear, hoping to tap into underlying conservatism and relying heavily on state power to hold onto power. This is all couched in an alternative narrative of patriotism, where Dataran Merdeka is portrayed as the place where challengers to power are putting the country governed by the BN under attack.

For the democratic nationalists in this equation, Bersih 3.0 was a mass rebellion. It was attacked, put down and described in such a manner that will build anger. The calls for Bersih 4.0 are already being voiced among supporters.

For the reactionary nationalists, Bersih 3.0 represents a revolutionary event that they have chosen to demonise, not fully realising that in doing so they are sowing the seeds of further discontent.

Supporters on this pole are demanding for arrests, with Bersih leaders and opposition activists top of the list, as they are blinded by authoritarian tools used in the Mahathir era that are outdated in Malaysia’s more mature polity.

Four fundamental mistakes

The reason that these narratives are so different is a continued misreading of Bersih 3.0. There are four fundamental mistakes that the reactionary nationalists made about the Bersih rally. First of all, they continue to equate the movement with the opposition.

This stems from a deep-seated fear of Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim. While both Pakatan Rakyat and the civil society-led Bersih movement share some common interests in reform, as do the overwhelming majority of Malaysians from across the political divide, they are not the same. Bersih represents a broad social movement that goes beyond opposition political leaders, and arguably even the Bersih leaders themselves.

It is about reform in governance and better representation, including on the part of opposition parties. This expansion of civil society into places such as Kota Kinabalu and Ipoh, as well as broadening within Kuala Lumpur itself, illustrates the new people-oriented politics of Malaysia. Elites on both sides will have to accommodate a more active and engaged public.

The days when people blindly follow the leaders or go to the streets for personalities alone are gone. Attacks on individual politicians in the wake of the rally just reveal a complete misunderstanding of the movement.

The second mistake of the reactionary nationalists is that Bersih 3.0 is about separate groups of Malaysians divided by ethnicity, organised by clearly ethnically divided groups. While ethnic identity remains important for Malaysian politics, for rally goers this was not about race, but about the country. The consistent theme is one of Malaysian identity, where one of the rally’s theme songs was ‘Negaraku’.

The impact of this public move to embrace non-ethnic politics is profound. In March 2008, voting across ethnic lines was largely private. The reality of common purpose came when the results came out.

Many of the motivations of March 2008 – Hindraf, religious rights and more – were ethnic in nature. Bersih 3.0 was markedly different. It was about a common purpose, where ethnicity was put aside in favour of community building. Bersih 3.0 was arguably the largest trust-building event in Malaysia’s history after Merdeka.

Malays, Chinese, Indians, Kadazans, Ibans and more met each other, shared laughter, water, sweets, salt… and tears. (The spillover is that it helps build trust among many opposition supporters who came to the rally, as well as the middle-ground Malaysians who met die-hard opposition members for the first time. For PAS in particular, perhaps the biggest success was its Amal security units, which were seen protecting rally-goers across races.)

After years of movement towards differences, towards less understanding, this was put aside on a hot afternoon. Bersih 3.0 has set in place conditions where trust building among ordinary people can grow stronger.

Ironically, the reactionary nationalists have underestimated the dissipation of fear in Malaysian politics. This is their third mistake. The bravery among Malaysians is growing. You do not need to look at the numbers of the crowd, although this should not be ignored.

You do not need to even look at the leaders of the movement or the examples of police officers who offered helping hands to rally goers while some of their peers were abusing their positions. Malaysians are increasingly willing to take ownership of their future and are willing to do so again.
Conservatively, the size of Bersih 3.0 doubled in less than a year. The authorities are fooling themselves if they think that these people will not stand up again. Bersih conservatively directly touched over 20 percent of the electorate and indirectly much more. The large participation of young people is especially important as they are traditionally the strongest risk-takers.

One student remarked to me afterwards how the taste of the tear gas the second time was sweeter and she was ready for more. Yes, a she. This is a less fearful Malaysia, and a more angrier one.

Finally, the reactionary nationalists appear to be mistakenly ignoring the issue behind the rally – electoral reform. Polling conducted in late 2011 shows before Bersih 3.0 that only a third of citizens think the electoral process is fair and free – very much in line with the Umno hardcore.
Whatever people think about the tactics and individuals in Bersih – and views differ – the overwhelming majority of Malaysians see a problem with the electoral system.

The government should bear in mind that globally, the single most important event that triggers political transitions is a fraudulent election. If the BN goes to the polls under the circumstances that are already widely seen to be unfair and lacking integrity, they are miscalculating the underlying sentiments of a growing number of people about the core issue of the rally.

They will be seen to be illegitimate by a large share of the population. This size of the rally should be sending clear signals to leaders to properly engage in electoral reform. Anything else will be seen by many as a desperate measure to hold onto power rather than a genuine mandate of a leader.

No compromises, only confrontation

Attention has centred on the timing of the polls. It looks more and more likely that these will occur as early as next month. Najib, over the past week, has embraced a hardline position, with an attempt to unite his base and papering over the divisions within Umno.

The media inundation of a turned-over car and the resultant violence aims to bring the rural base back into the BN fold. To add onto this, the hardline efforts involving personal attacks – with bizarre photos bordering on pornography on the front-page of national newspapers and complete fabrications of speeches – reflects the beginnings of an assault on the opposition and international observers.

These tactics coupled with the embedded advantages in the electoral system and support from East Malaysia appear to form the strategy that is perceived to bring a BN victory, albeit one that will be highly contentious.

To follow the path of confrontation rather than compromise is very risky. First of all, it ignores the elephant in the room associated with elections, the need for the elections to be seen as legitimate.

To date, the government’s outreach to Bersih is missing and genuine avenues for electoral reform remain unexplored. While Bersih faces the challenge of illustrating the need for reforms and moving the movement forward, its central message has resonated among many Malaysians. The greater the demonisation and distancing away from Bersih, the harder compromise is possible.
Second, it assumes that Najib can control the actors who are carrying out hardline manoeuvres. Already the Umno-linked New Straits Times has been internationally shamed. How many other institutions will have to compromise themselves in this battle for power, in which more authoritarian measures are adopted?

What makes the current environment complex for the current leadership is that even its own actors on the BN side have become more non-state in nature and are increasingly mobilised, making this move toward legitimising hardline approaches even more risky.

Letting this sort of politics rule reflects on the leadership. Physics teaches us that with every action there is another reaction. Hardline options provoke hardline responses. This dynamic will serve to polarise the electorate into political camps and harden positions in these camps. The days of polarisation of families post-1999 reformasi are coming again, but with even greater intensity given the mobilisation of the young.

Finally, this apparent choice by Najib to embrace the hardline political path will make it even harder to bring about any reform in any realm. To de-link economic reform from political change is unviable. There is a need to implement the rule of law fairly to promote the economy, and this involves a fair and unbiased investigation.

To give in to the hardline political position will undermine economic reform and contribute to the bad practices of using resources to win political allies rather than in building a sustainable and inclusive economy.

Indeed, the miscalculations of a growing social movement by reactionary nationalists will make Najib’s national leadership even more vulnerable.

The title was inspired by a Bersih 3.0 protester, whose remarks on BBC was censored by local satellite TV station Astro.

净选盟3.0 - 大马人政治意识改善












        净选盟号召的净选盟3.0集会,虽然发生一些不愉快的事情,但大致上可看到马来西亚人政治意识的突破,这包括几方面。

        一、敢站出来表态。向来大马人对政治不敢公开谈,有者是政治冷淡症候群,有者是怕惹事,有者是消极主义等。709净选盟2.0集会在各种恐惧阴影下,都有多达5万人参与。这也有助于使到一些人突破恐惧作参与428净选盟3.0的决定。

        这次不同的是警方没有上次大动作设路障检查进入吉隆坡的车辆,也没有预先逮捕穿黄衣人士。这明显看到政府对于集会开放有点进步。遗憾美中不足乃警方用不恰当的形式驱散人群。吉隆坡有25万人,加上东西马各城镇集会,及全球35个国家于85个地点的大马人集会共有几万人,他们为的是表态支持改革大马的选举制度达到自由与公平。除此,我们相信没有参与集会的人士,并不等于是不支持这项制度的。

        二、敢站出来争取人权。自由集会是一个先进国的标志,所以那里的人民有集会的权力。我们离开先进国目标只有8年,不长,因此当权者不应该以过去一般的抑制作风,而是应该提供集会的方便。政府原本可以从净选盟2.0的经历来给予3.0开放政策,开放独立广场。这次比上次多了几倍人数,可看到是一种“越压抑越反弹”的现象。

        三、摒弃种族宗教的政治形式。大马人一向来都是爱好和平的,发生有人滋事,并不表示人民要使用暴力来达到诉求的意愿。这次发生一些乱象,但却有许多疑点待解释。若真的有人冲破在拉惹路独立广场的障碍围篱的话,大可逮捕那些人士。

        人群其实分布在很广泛的各处,大多数人并不知道发生在拉惹路的事情。人民所知道的乃集会是下午2时至4时,当时是约3时15分,很自然地没想到要离开的。可是水炮车却此时在各处喷射水,及到处发射催泪弹。鸡飞狗走的人群有人绊倒,人民不分种族宗教去协助他们。许多人吸入催泪弹烟雾,人民也不分种族宗教地提供水和盐给他们。其实在1970年代之前大马人的生活乃不分种族宗教地相处的,这种现象消失了这么多年,回复昔日的和睦相处乃是人民所渴求的。

        我们欣喜看到马来西亚人民对政治的醒觉,政治并不可怕,回避政治才可怕。国家是属于全体人民的,不是属于一小撮的政治人物的。当人民有政治意识时,这等于人人扮演制衡和监督的角色,那么被投选出来的人民代议士就会更谨慎地治理政务。

Saturday, May 5, 2012

SUHAKAM Inquiry On Police Violence On April 28


Bersih 2.0
Saturday, 05 May 2012 16:25

While the government focuses on the breaching of the barricades at Dataran Merdeka by a few, and what they see as a threat to their power, there is a deafening and irresponsible silence about the unprecedented violence inflicted upon unsuspecting members of the public by the police force.
Whilst BERSIH 2.0 does not condone the breaching of the barricades, the legality of those barricades is questionable, as is the legality of the hurriedly obtained court order. We are also receiving information that much more was happening at the barricades than meets the eye.
The unanswered question still remains – who is responsible for the untold violence upon participants of the Duduk Bantah that occurred after the first tear gas was fired?
Evidence based on medical reports of some of those who were detained by the police appear to show that some members of the police force were out to punish those who wore BERSIH 3.0 t-shirts, anti-Lynas t-shirts or any yellow t-shirts, by inflicting excessive and completely unjustified violence on them.
Some detainees were attacked at the time of arrest, when they were in shops dining, or about to board LRTs while others were attacked after arrest and despite the absence of struggle. Some were alleged to have been assaulted by over 30 police personnel. Many speak of having to "run the gauntlet" of police personnel and beaten repeatedly before being loaded onto police trucks.
The brutality suggests that a segment of the police force on duty that day had acted with vengeance against BERSIH 3.0 participants whether due to orders given to them or because they had lost control. There are too many reports of police officers who were wearing blue police uniforms but without their names and police identity numbers so as to prevent the victims of violence from identifying the perpetrators of police violence.
In addition to BERSIH 3.0 participants, it must not be forgotten that more than 12 photographers and journalists were assaulted, intimidated or detained by police while reporting the rally, and cameras, memory cards and video equipment were taken away.
Given the violence towards members of the media, we find it shameful that fellow members of the mainstream media continue with their blatant censorship of the news on the violence committed against civilians by the police. It is at this critical time that the media must step up to the plate, serve the interests of justice and report the truth and the whole truth. In not doing so, they fail the rakyat and their fellow journalists, many of whom (including those in the mainstream media) are now bravely voicing their concerns. We support these journalists who are claiming their rights as professionals.
The proposed independent panel
The "independent panel" that is to be set up is to apparently look into violence against journalists only. What of violence against the other participants? Is that unimportant to the government? BERSIH 2.0 calls upon SUHAKAM to conduct an urgent independent inquiry into one of the most extensive acts of violence perpetrated by the authorities upon the people of Malaysia.
The Rejection of Stadium Merdeka
As to the rejection of the stadium by BERSIH as a reason for the violence, this is wholly without basis. The offer for Stadium Merdeka came too late for BERSIH 2.0 to re-organize its event. It is evident from the vast number of people who turned up that day that any change in venue at the last minute would have created certain chaos on the day. We were therefore right in the decision not to change venue at short notice.
In hindsight, we believe it was also a good thing not to have accepted the Stadium Merdeka. Given the conduct and ill intent of some of the police force, the Stadium would have been a trap that would have been wholly unsafe for the participants.
Overthrowing the Government?
As far as the statement about overthrowing the government is concerned, BERSIH 2.0 rejects it entirely. BERSIH2.0 wants free and fair elections. The Government has not explained how occupying Dataran Merdeka constitutes a threat to Government, or an attempt to overthrow the Government.
It is our wish that any changes to those who will ultimately represent us in government be made through the ballot box in elections that are clean and fair.
Which brings us back again to BERSIH’s demands. Are they all going to be implemented before the 13th G.E.? Are the EC Chairman and Deputy Chairman going to be asked to step down if it is confirmed they are UMNO members?
Those that choose to ignore the cry of over 250,000 people for clean and fair elections, by labeling it something else, insult the intelligence of the people. What we want is for candidates who win the elections to do so honorably. And what we need to see now are statesmen and stateswomen who handle the grievances of the people sensitively and responsibly.
Steering Committee - Coalition for Clean and Fair Elections 2.0 (BERSIH 2.0)

Source: http://www.malaysianmirror.com/media-buzz-detail/136-letters-to-the-editor/57592-suhakam-inquiry-on-police-violence-on-april-28

Friday, May 4, 2012

Violence against Malaysia



A:

Zan Azlee is a documentary filmmaker, journalist, writer, New Media practitioner and lecturer. He runs Fat Bidin Media www.fatbidin.com

May 04, 2012
MAY 4 — I waited for almost a week before actually writing or posting anything much about the recent Bersih 3.0 rally in Kuala Lumpur. There were so many emotions, I wanted to make sure that I was calm and coherent before actually commenting on it.
And now that everything seems ever so slightly clearer to me, the one thing that affected me most that Saturday was the violence that occurred.
The day had started early for me and walking all around the city, I felt the almost party-like atmosphere amongst all the Malaysians that had gathered.
Dataran Merdeka, of course, had a heavy police presence. It was cordoned off with metal fencing and even scary-looking barbed wire.
But, as I mentioned, the atmosphere was very festive and I guess the intimidation wasn’t working that well.
When the rally was in full force, I was standing alongside the leaders as they were giving their speeches and encouraging the people to sing.
Once everyone was as close to Dataran Merdeka as possible, I heard the leaders declaring the rally a success and calling for the crowd to disperse.
The crowd didn’t disperse and I made my way behind the barricade and police line with the help of my press tag.
Before I knew it, I heard people shouting and noticed the police running back from the barricade. The protesters had breached the barricade.
The police, of course, went into full riot mode with their helmets and gas masks on, carrying their shields. Tear gas was fired and the water cannons came out.
Here we go, I thought to myself. This wasn’t the first rally I had covered and I knew the drill and for the next hour or so, things weren’t really out of the ordinary.
People were screaming and taunting the police, challenging the authorities, just like at any demonstration and the police went out trying to disperse the large crowd.
From my observations, the police managed to actually successfully keep the crowd away from the Dataran Merdeka area.
But what happened next was something that I had never seen or experienced before. It was when the violence started.
Groups of policemen suddenly started attacking the protesters. They would gang up on individuals and just unleash punches and kicks.
I, along with many other journalists who were there, started shooting these attacks and arrests. Usually, on previous occasions like this, what would happen is that the police would realise the press was there watching and they would stop any aggression.
This happened at Bersih 2.0 in 2011 and there were times when I would run up to where police were roughing up people just so they would stop.
But last Saturday was different. When we journalists started documenting what was happening, we instead ended up on the receiving end of the aggression.
The police started screaming at us in a very hostile way to stop shooting. I had police shoving my camera arms, pulling and pushing me away.
At one point, I was even detained by the police who had accused me of shooting a group of them (around 20, I think) beating up a protester.
I didn’t want my equipment to be confiscated or to be arrested, so I denied shooting any video of the pounding. They let me off the hook with a stern warning.
I was lucky. Many of my other colleagues were assaulted and attacked just for doing their jobs. They were punched and kicked and suffered terrible injuries.
Their equipment was confiscated and many even had their cameras and lenses smashed and destroyed.
I also noticed something very strange. At one point, I saw that all the policemen who were in uniform had removed their Velcro nametags.
They were also moving in droves away from Dataran Merdeka and into the streets and they were just attacking, beating and arresting people.
Since I was witnessing all this and could not shoot anything, I started feeling sick to the stomach and decided to just walk to where I had parked my car and go home.
While I was walking along the sidewalk, I could see these policemen on the streets still going after people and beating them and arresting them.
And as I was walking, I even saw several injured people unconscious on the ground and being picked up by ambulances.
There were many passers-by along the street too and they had stopped to look. Some were shooting with mobile phones. I even heard someone shouting for the police to stop.
A group of men stopped me and asked if I was a member of the press. I said yes and they asked to be interviewed.
I looked over my shoulder to see if there were any policemen close by. But none were since they were too busy doing what they were doing.
The men told me that they had never seen anything like this before. They said it looked like a bunch of cats going wild in the back alleys looking for mice.
They told me that they felt disgusted. One of them even said that he was a retired policeman and he had never done anything of this sort during his career.
Once they were done expressing their feelings, I turned off my camera. Walked into the parking lot where my car was and drove off to go home and hug my daughter.
That Saturday, I had never felt so angry before. Angry because my fellow journalists and I were threatened and assaulted for doing our jobs.
In all my years as a journalist, I have never felt as threatened and intimidated as I did that day. And I am one who has reported in conflict zones such as Afghanistan, Lebanon and Pattani.
If the police felt like they were justified in what they were doing, why then did they not allow journalists to document it?
That Saturday, I also felt very sad. Sad because I witnessed so many of my fellow Malaysians suffer at the hands of those who were supposed to protect them.
There is so much noise right now in the country.
This side accusing that side of breaching the barricades, and that side accusing this side of not complying with the law.
This side accusing that side of being unjust, and that side accusing this side of not being reasonable.
Like I said, this is all just noise.
I have never begged before. But I am begging now. I am begging that we Malaysians keep our eyes on the ball and do what is best for our country.
* The views expressed here are the personal views of the columnist.

Bersih 3.0 – Malaysia, Freedom from Oppression









This video clip was shot by me:

I must say my contribution to the fight for justice in Malaysia is very minute. For participating in Bersih rallies, I just hoped to add myself to the total number for one more soul. This article is not only my recount of my Bersih 3.0 story, but also a comment about its impact.

I had several experiences in protest rallies including the Bersih 2.0 one. I got myself prepared for Bersih 3.0 rally even before it was announced.

I participated in the rally as a responsible Christian Minister as well as a Malaysian citizen. I cannot tolerate the corrupt practices by the present government. I remembered the words of Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr, “Freedom is never voluntarily given by the oppressor; it must be demanded by the oppressed.” Bersih rallies are about asking for free and fair Elections. I cannot tolerate any political coalition to take governance through dirty means. As such I cannot sit at home and let others to protest for me.

I took pains to request the Bersih organizing committee to hold the rally on a Saturday and not a Sunday. I was grateful to them as Bersih 2.0 was also on a Saturday. I have anticipated that this time around there would be many Christian participants since the Church has awakened to engaging in politics.

As what I did for Bersih 2.0, I lodged in Kuala Lumpur center with two other friends. I could sense that something was different from Bersih 2.0. Those days the atmosphere was very tense. The authorities declared that Bersih was an illegal organization and subsequently anything related to Bersih was illegal, including their shirts, caps and badges. Ironically, prior to the Bersih 2.0 rally, some people were even arrested for wearing a yellow shirt! They intimidated people constantly, warning them not to take part in the rally or else they would have to face the music.

So those days we had to take a commuter train service to KL to avoid road-checks. This time round we drove to KL despite they still used the “scare” tactics, though not quite similar than last year. The mayor for KL City Hall Ahmad Fuad Ismail had obtained a court order to ban the people from entering Dataran Merdeka (DM) which was our venue for the rally.

It was reported that he told that he would not close roads to DM, but as a matter of fact, roads were closed. Bersih insisted in using DM as it has the significance of independence. Barisan Nasional has bound the people for 55 years, and it is the time for us to cry for freedom from their slavery. Who was that non-elected mayor who banned the people from using DM? DM belonged to all Malaysians and the mayor and BN leaders have no rights own them alone. When they cordoned off DM, it conveyed a message that BN was colonizing the people.

The necessity to take things to streets

Not many would think like me. Even Christian Ministers would argue that prayer would sufficiently spur change, and they doubted the necessity to take things to streets. I urged Christians not to pray at home but pray at DM.

It is true that it is never the first option for most people to engage street protest in order to express their discontentment against regimes. It always happened only when all avenues were exhausted. When the authorities do not want to listen to the people, when they do not want to reform to bless their own people, and when they sealed up the mouth of the public by controlling the media, the only avenue for the people is to take matters into the streets. What took place in the Arab world was not something erupted suddenly. The Arab Spring has seen the dictators overthrown!

Bersih 2.0 was organized because our present electoral system is not free and fair. So Bersih committee came up with eight petitions for electoral reform. The government then set up a Parliamentary Select Committee to study into the matter. Unfortunately, after 7 months, the PSC only adopted one out of the eight items. Other suggestions recommended by the PSC were insignificant. It was for show that the government is committee to reforms.

Something serious took place on the last day of the second session of Parliament this year (19 April, 2012). Nine bills were passed just on a single day! The speed was sufficient for BN to win an Oscar award for Comedian Movies. It is another “Malaysia Boleh” and “Only in Malaysia” indeed! The new bills included an amendment on “The Election Offenses Act 1954” to the disadvantage of the Oppositions.

This bill alone is justified to hold Bersih 3.0 rally. This bill was so secretive that it escaped the attention of the Members of Parliament on both divides. Prime Minister Najib had told the people that he wanted to create the most ever transparent government in Malaysian history. Now with this ridiculous bill passed, what kind of transparency can we bank on him?

The electoral roll is full of thousands of phantom voters. Names that are not found in the Mykad department were registered as voters. There were voters being transferred to other constituencies, some even away from their resident states. There were voters who have been voting in the past found their names missing.

Bersih rally in KL had 250,000 to 300,000 participants. Besides, rallies were held in other cities and towns throughout Malaysia. Globally they were held in 35 countries and 85 locations. With the wrath of so many people, the government should bow to the message of the public. They should heed the petitions of the people. They should commit to electoral reform before the next General Elections.

On the day of the rally, people gathered in six meeting points beginning at 6.00 am. More than 30 roads leading to the city were closed. For Light Rail Transport, some stations were closed. At about 1.30 pm, people began to move nearer to DM. The crowd was so big that it overflowed to cover up many roads and streets around DM.

The gathering was peaceful. People sang Negaraku, our national anthem. The people also chanted slogans such as “Hidup Hidup, Hidup Bersih”, “No to Lynas”, and others. At 2.30 pm my friends and I moved to other streets. We tried to squeeze through the crowd at Masjid Jamek LRT station but to no avail. So we came to the river-side for chatting. Many people were scattered here and there all around.

We began to move back to the Bar Council at about 3.20 pm. The Bersih 3.0 organizing chairman Ambiga did dismiss the crowd shortly before we moved away. But most of the people including us did not get the news. After a while a water cannon truck at the Bar Council sprayed jets of chemical-laced water all around. The crowd was fleeing and screaming. I took the opportunity to video the precious incident at a distance of 50 meters away.

About 2 minutes later, I heard a few sounds of “Pak Pak Pak…” I thought the tear gas was fired in front of me but for some time I saw no smoke. I then turned around and to my horror more than three canisters were smoking behind me, the nearest one being only 10 meters away. I dashed through the dense smoke by holding my breath. Out of panic I forgot to pull out my handkerchief from the real pocket of my trousers. Instead, I took out my porous webcam pocket to cover my nose and mouth. I could not hold back my breath for too long, and subsequently I sucked in the smoke through my nose and mouth. My eyes, nose and throat stung.

When I was at a safe place, I quickly sucked some bamboo salt, rinsed my mouth, drank some water, and washed my eyes. I shared my salt with others, Malays and Chinese.

When I went back to Jalan Sultan, only did I find that the police did similar attacks at many points. The people fled here from all over the streets. People recounted their ordeal that the police were entrapping the people with tear gas from all angles. That was malicious! The right way to do is not by attacking the unarmed protesters but by dispersing them without harming them.

The brutality of the police was disgusting

From the online media, I read about the violence done by the police. They beat up the protesters. They even intruded into the restaurant and harassed the customers who wore yellow shirts. The journalists were not spared. Many of them were beaten and their cameras being seized. How can we expect BN to lead us into an advanced and democratic country when we see what they did was so barbaric? They did not even respect the International Law that that says they cannot harm journalists? The Home Minister Hishamuddin claimed that deleting photos was a Standard of Procedure. The next day the Inspector-General of Police Ismail Omar clarified that it is not a SOP. How come a Home Minister was so ignorant about his trade?

The National Union of Journalist has asked the Home Minister and the IGP to apologize. On 3 May is World Press Freedom Day. The four Chinese newspapers, Sin Chew, China Press, Nanyang and Guang Ming, have asked the public to dress in black on that day. As at the time of this article published, both of them still owed the journalists an apology.

The brutality of the police was disgusting. They arrested 512 people. The attack by police on the protesters started when some people breached the barricades. Was it a good excuse to take action? The Bar Council was right that they said the court order only ban the people from DM. Though people got into the barricade they were still outside of DM. According to Ambiga, it was likely some sabotage as the people were gathering peacefully thus far. Well, those were agent provocateurs. It sounds so familiar about the claim from what took place in many gatherings of Pakatan Rakyat which were being harassed by rascals!

The greatest loser in Bersih 3.0

Who is the greatest loser in Bersih 3.0? Najib! Remember in Bersih 2.0, before the rally, Ambiga hoped to meet up with Najib but her wish did not take place. He dumped all the responsibility to the IGP. In Bersih 3.0, prior to the rally, Najib was so silent about it. He dumped all the responsibility to the Home Minister. The later was flip-flopping. At first he said he had no problem with the rally. Then he dumped all the problems to the mayor. And the mayor dumped all the problems to the IGP.

I could relate the story of Exodus with the dilemma of Najib. When Moses asked Pharaoh to allow the Israelites to leave Egypt, God was behind it. God told Moses He would harden the heart of Pharaoh. When Pharaoh refused to let God’s people go, actually it was God who had hardened his heart. For Bersih 2.0 and 3.0, God has hardened the heart of Najib. That spoke why he made the wrong decisions. When man is behind a move, it will fail. But when God is behind it, it will succeed.

After the rally on 428, the next day, the atmosphere all around Malaysia became fresher. But our struggle does not end here. We still need to tussle hard with the evil forces in order to bring down the corrupt regime. Hidup Rakyat! Bangkit Rakyat! Hidup Bersih! Hallelujah, Malaysia shall enter into the year of Jubilee soon. Probably the General Elections will be delayed further to September or later.

Please take note that on 16 September this year, Malaysia will be finishing her 49 years of slavery, and on this day we will enter into the 50th year, the year of Jubilee according to the Bible. Malaysia shall be free from the oppression by BN. Malaysia shall become a Rainbow Nation. Rainbow – a symbol of diversity. Our diverse races shall come to fruition as everyone is a Malaysian!

Wednesday, May 2, 2012

428大集会‧“警方过度暴力执法”‧律师公会报告揭9现象


  • 林志伟:律师公会当天派出约78名律师到现场监督整个集会情况。(图:星洲日报)
(吉隆坡1日讯)大马律师公会公佈428黄绿静坐抗议大集会的初步报告,指责警方以暴力执行任务,並且过度执法。
律师公会主席林志伟在新闻发佈会上说,政府是时候设立“独立警察投诉与行为不检委员会”(IPCMC)了。根据律师公会观察员的观察,跟去年的709净选盟2.0大集会比较,警方这次使用更多的暴力,更加任意地使用催泪弹和水砲。
促设警察投诉行为委会
他说,律师公会当天派出约78名律师到现场监督整个集会情况,初步报告共列出以下9种现象。
1.在下午约3时,集会都是和平地进行,直到警方发射水炮和催泪弹时,场面才出现混乱。
2.警方使用高压手段,包括在没有受到任何明显的挑衅下,发射多轮的催泪弹,以及任意发射水炮。
3.警方使用暴力日益广泛。
4.有跡象显示,警方防止和制止人们记录警方的行动和处理方式。
5.警方直接向人群发射催泪弹,甚至不让集会者有机会快速解散,因此,这不是在驱散,而是在“攻击”人群。
6.警方使用不法行为对付集会者,並且含有报復心態。
7.警方存有嘲弄人群之嫌。
8.当有警员遭人群丟掷物品时,警方也“有样学样”。